2498 Perry Crossing Way Ste 105, Plainfield, IN 46168 317-203-9107
2498 Perry Crossing Way Ste 105, Plainfield, IN 46168 317-203-9107
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

LUNCH

The Theo's Italian culinary team has created a diverse Italian menu that changes seasonally and features a variety of local ingredients. Our housemade pastas & Roman style pizza are our featured items.

Salad

  • House

    Spinach | Romaine | Tomato | Fennel | Mozzarella | Parmesan | Red Wine Vinaigrette

    gluten free, vegetarian

  • Arugula

    Spinach | Fennel | Pine Nut | Pecorino | Pickled Red Onion | Pesto | Honey-Lemon Vinaigrette

    gluten free, vegetarian

  • Brussels Sprouts Caesar

    Romaine | Swiss Chard | Shaved Parmesan | Pancetta | Olive Salad | Focaccia Crouton | Caesar Dressing

  • Chopped

    Romaine | Salami | Egg | Crispy Pancetta | Pickled Red Onion | Tomato | Gorgonzola | Parmesan | Mediterranean Vinaigrette

    gluten free

Soup

  • Minestrone

    vegetarian

  • Parmesan Chicken Pastina

Build Your Own Pizza 7"

Crushed Tomato & Mozzarella

  • Build Your Own 7" Pizza

    (choose one)
    Pepperoni | Sausage | Chicken | Mushroom | Olive | Red Pepper

    Additional Toppings $1 - $1.50

    Choose a Specialty Pizza $3

Vegan

Vegetarian

Gluten-Free

*Consuming raw or undercooked foods increases the chance of food-borne illness. Please inform your server of any allergies.

  • Slide 1 of 2
  • Slide 2 of 2

    • Dinner

    The Theo's Italian culinary team has created a diverse Italian menu that changes seasonally and features a variety of local ingredients. Our housemade pastas & Roman style pizza are our featured items.

    Starters

    • Soup

      $6

      Minestrone vg | Parmesan Chicken Pastina

    • Breadsticks

      $7

      (choose one)
      Marinara | Cheese Sauce | Garlic Butter | Alfredo

      vegetarian

    • Burrata & Focaccia

      $14

      Artichoke | Tomato | Basil Pesto | Chili-Garlic Crunch

      vegetarian

    • Italian Meatballs

      $12

      Pomodoro | Basil | Parmesan

    • Fried Calamari & Shrimp

      $15

      Calabrian Chili Aioli | Lemon

    • Antipasti Board

      $18

      Fresh Mozzarella | Herbed Goat Cheese | Seared Parmesan | Genoa Salami | Soppressata | Prosciutto | Focaccia Crostini | Pesto | Tomato | Agrodolce | Pickled Red Onion

    Salad

    Add Chicken +$5 | Crispy Calamari +$6 | Shrimp +$6

    • House gf vg

      $8

      Spinach | Romaine | Tomato | Fennel | Mozzarella | Parmesan | Red Wine Vinaigrette

    • Arugula gf vg

      $9

      Spinach | Fennel | Pine Nut | Pecorino | Pickled Red Onion | Pesto | Honey-Lemon Vinaigrette

    • Brussels Sprouts Caesar

      $9

      Romaine | Swiss Chard | Shaved Parmesan | Pancetta | Olive Salad | Focaccia Crouton | Caesar Dressing

    • Chopped gf

      $9

      Romaine | Salami | Egg | Crispy Pancetta | Pickled Red Onion | Tomato | Gorgonzola | Parmesan | Mediterranean Vinaigrette

    Sandwiches

    Served with House Chips | Sub House Salad or Soup +$3

    • Italian

      $16

      Genoa Salami | Pepperoni | Mortadella | Provolone | Lettuce | Tomato | Banana Pepper | Onion | Red Wine Vinaigrette | Hoagie Roll

    • Meatball

      $15

      Pomodoro | Mozzarella | Parmesan | Basil Pesto | Hoagie Roll

    • Caprese

      $15

      Burrata | Tomato | Arugula | Balsamic | Basil Pesto | Focaccia

      vegetarian

    • Chicken Parmesan

      $16

      Breaded Chicken | Mozzarella | Pomodoro | Hoagie Roll

    Fresh Pastas

    Made In-house Daily, Includes Breadstick

    • Bucatini & Meatball

      $18

      Pomodoro | Basil | Parmesan

    • Ziti

      $20

      Sausage | Red Pepper | Onion | Mozzarella | Chili-Garlic Crunch | Swiss Chard | Parmesan

    • Four Cheese Ravioli

      $18

      Ricotta | Gorgonzola | Parmesan | Mascarpone | Pomodoro | Frico | Garlic Chip | Basil

      vegetarian

    • Lobster Tortellini Nero

      $24

      Ricotta | Calamari | Shrimp | Garlic | Tomato | Red Chili | Swiss Chard | White Wine Cream

    • Tagliatelle Arrabbiata

      $21

      Shrimp | Pancetta | Zucchini | Calabrian Chili | Pomodoro

    • Casarecce

      $21

      Beef & Pork Ragù | Pecorino | Swiss Chard | Shallot | Garlic | Butter

    • Linguine

      $18

      Chicken | Alfredo | Garlic

    • Lasagna

      $22

      Bolognese | Ricotta | Mozzarella | Parmesan Cream | Garlic Chip

    Specialty Housemade Pizzas

    14" (Feeds 1-2)

    • Margherita

      $15

      Crushed Tomato | Fresh Mozzarella | Garlic | Basil | Parmesan | Olive Oil

    • The Potato

      $16

      Pancetta | White Cheddar | Crème Fraîche | Chive | Parmesan Cream

    • Truffled Mushroom Sausage

      $18

      Truffle Oil | Crushed Tomato | Pecorino

    • Pesto Chicken

      $17

      Parmesan Cream | Oil-Cured Tomato | Mozzarella | Parmesan | Red Onion

    • Sweet Heat

      $18

      Crushed Tomato | Mozzarella | Soppressata | Sausage | Jalapeño | Crushed Red Pepper | Honey

    • Meat Sweats

      $19

      Sausage | Pepperoni | Pancetta | Prosciutto | Red Sauce | Mozzarella | Parmesan

    • Veggie

      $16

      Zucchini | Mushroom | Oil-Cured Tomato | Black Olive | Red Onion | Artichoke | Pesto

      vegetarian

    • Fig Pig Goat

      $18

      Fig Jam | Prosciutto | Goat Cheese | Pecorino | Arugula | Pickled Onion | Honey Garlic

    Build Your Own Pizza 14"

    $12 (Feeds 1-2)

    • Sauce

      (choose one)
      Crushed Tomato | Parmesan Cream | Pomodoro | Basil Pesto | EVOO

    • Cheese

      (choose one)
      Mozzarella | Ricotta | Pecorino | White Cheddar | Goat Cheese | Gorgonzola

    • Meats

      $3

      Meatball | Pancetta | Sausage | Pepperoni | Prosciutto | Chicken | Soppressata

    • Veggies

      $2

      Zucchini | Mushroom | Onion | Fennel | Artichoke | Black Olive | Banana Pepper | Red Pepper | Jalapeño

    Vegan

    Vegetarian

    Gluten-Free

    *Consuming raw or undercooked foods increases the chance of food-borne illness. Please inform your server of any allergies.

  • Slide 1 of 4
  • Slide 2 of 4
  • Slide 3 of 4
  • Slide 4 of 4

    • Dessert

    Dessert

    • Italian Cream Cake

      $10

      Cream Cheese Icing | Coconut | Pecan | Wafer Cookie

      vegetarian

    • Cheesecake

      $10

      Graham Cracker Crust | Strawberry Compote

      vegetarian

    • Tiramisu

      $10

      Mascarpone Mousse | Ladyfinger | Espresso | Chocolate Pudding | Cocoa

    • Gelato

      $7

      (choose one)
      Strawberry | Raspberry Sorbet

      gluten free, vegetarian

    Vegan

    Vegetarian

    Gluten-Free

  • Slide 1 of 3
  • Slide 2 of 3
  • Slide 3 of 3

    • Beverages

    Download PDF

    Theo's Classic

    • The Usual

      $12

      Compoveda | Soda | Lime

    • Negroni Sbagliato

      $14

      The Botanist Gin | Volume Primo Vermouth | Campari | Moscato | Orange

    • Godfather Sour

      $14

      Woodford Reserve Bourbon | Compass Box Artist Blend Scotch | Lazzaroni Amaretto | Lemon | Bitters

    • Italian Bird

      $12

      Plantation Pineapple Rum | Campari | Tio Pepe Fino Sherry | Salted Honey | Passionfruit | Lime

    • Blueberry Basil

      $12

      Basil Infused Tito’s Handmade Vodka | Blueberry Fruitful | Dry Curacao | Lemon | Thai Green Chili

    • Theo’s Old Fashioned

      $10

      Knob Creek Rye | Brown Sugar | Bay Leaf | Bitters

    • Italian Margarita

      $12

      Jose Cuervo Tradicional Silver Tequila | Heirloom Pineapple Amaro | Lime | Pineapple | Agave

    • Espresso Martini

      $12

      Somrus Coffee Cream Liqueur | Averna Amaro | Absolut Vodka | Espresso

    • Rum Rendezvous

      $12

      Captain Morgan | Bacardi Silver Rum | Peach Schnapps | Orange | Pineapple | Grenadine

    Spritz

    • Almare Grapefruit Spritz

      $10

    • Almare Elderflower Spritz

      $10

    • Aperol Spritz

      $12

    Beer Bottles & Cans

    • Peroni

      $8

    • Stella Artois

      $8

    • Coors Light

      $6

    • Miller Lite

      $6

    • Budweiser

      $6

    • Michelob Ultra

      $6

    • Corona

      $8

    • Blue Moon

      $8

    • Guinness

      $8

    • Fat Tire

      $8

    • Heineken

      $7

    • Heineken 0.0

      $7

    • Gumballhead

      $8

      3 Floyds Brewing
      Munster, Indiana
      American Wheat Pale Ale | 5.6%

    • Zombie Dust

      $8

      3 Floyds Brewing
      Munster, Indiana
      American Pale Ale | 6.5%

    • Two Hearted IPA

      $8

      Bell’s Brewery
      Comstock, Michigan
      American IPA | 7%

    • Oberon Ale

      $8

      Bell’s Brewery
      Comstock, Michigan
      American Wheat Ale | 5.8%

    • Six Foot Blonde

      $8

      Quaff ON! Brewing Company
      Nashville, Indiana
      Blonde Ale | 4.5%

    • Six Foot Strawberry Blonde

      $8

      Quaff ON! Brewing Company
      Nashville, Indiana
      Strawberry Blonde Ale | 5.2%

    • Sunlight Cream Ale

      $8

      Sun King Brewery
      Indianapolis, Indiana
      Cream Ale | 5.3%

    • Dragonfly IPA

      $8

      Upland Brewing Co.
      Bloomington, Indiana
      IPA | 6.7%

    Sparkling by the Glass

    • Vigneti del Sole Prosecco “1925”

      Treviso, Italy

      Glass $11

      Bottle $43

    • Tintero Moscato d’Asti

      Piedmont, Italy

      Glass $10

      Bottle $39

    White by the Glass

    • Tiefenbrunner Pinot Grigio

      Vigneti delle Dolomiti, Italy

      Glass $11

      Bottle $43

    • J. de Villebois Sauvignon Blanc “Touraine”

      Loire Valley, France

      Glass $12

      Bottle $47

    • Pieropan Soave

      Veneto, Italy

      Glass $12

      Bottle $47

    • M. Dean Chardonnay

      California

      Glass $10

      Bottle $39

    • Fess Parker Riesling

      Central Coast, California

      Glass $9

      Bottle $35

    Rosé by the Glass

    • Duca Salapatura Rosato “Calanica”

      Sicily, Italy

      Glass $11

      Bottle $43

    Red by the Glass

    • The Pinot Project Pinot Noir

      California

      Glass $11

      Bottle $43

    • Castello di Bossi Chianti Classico

      Tuscany, Italy

      Glass $13

      Bottle $51

    • Scarpetta Barbera del Monferrato

      Piedmont, Italy

      Glass $12

      Bottle $47

    • Falesco Vitiano Rosso

      Umbria, Italy

      Glass $11

      Bottle $43

    • Routestock Cabernet Sauvignon

      Napa Valley, California

      Glass $15

      Bottle $59

  • Slide 1 of 2
  • Slide 2 of 2

    • Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Reservations

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thanks!
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.